Owner Surrender
Love for all living beings is the noblest quality of man.
- Charles Darwin
Gentle Spirit Horses Rescue is a Full Circle of Life, open-door organization. This means we accept horses of all ages, breeds, and conditions—including those who are elderly, injured, or unhandled—because every horse deserves safety and compassion.
Surrendering your horse can be a difficult decision, but it is a compassionate and selfless act that can make a world of difference for your equine companion and others in need. By doing so, you are providing your horse with the opportunity to receive the care and attention it needs, especially if you are no longer able to provide for them, and giving your horse its best chance at safety and staying out of the slaughter and auction pipeline.
Thank you for trusting us with your horse - we are here to help!

PLEASE NOTE: WE ARE CURRENTLY ON A WAIT LIST
Due to high demand and limited space, we are currently operating on a wait list for owner surrenders. The estimated wait time is approximately 8–12 weeks. If you are seeking to surrender a horse, please complete our intake form to join the list. We regularly coordinate with trusted partner organizations and may be able to place horses sooner depending on urgency and specific needs.
We prioritize horses located in South Dakota and neighboring states. We receive many requests from far outside our region—sometimes several hundred to thousands of miles away. While we wish we could help every horse, our mission and resources are focused on our local area. Unless there is a compelling reason, we are unlikely to be able to accept horses from beyond our regional focus.
If your situation is urgent, please note that clearly on your form. Emergencies are reviewed individually and we will do our best to respond quickly.
We also encourage you to reach out to other reputable rescues:
- Miniature horses or ponies: Little Hooves Mini Horse Rescue near White, SD
- Older or senior horses: Borderlands Horse Sanctuary or This Old Horse in Minnesota
- West River, South Dakota: Happy Tails Haven Horse Rescue & Sanctuary in Piedmont, SD
- Nebraska: MJM Horse Rescue in Dunbar, NE
- Colorado: Colorado Horse Rescue Network based in Rush, CO
- Additional networking resources: The Right Horse Initiative and The Full Circle of Life Network
Thank you for your patience and understanding as we work to help as many horses as we can.

SURRENDER PROCESS & Intake FEE
Gentle Spirit Horses Rescue is a Full Circle of Life, open-door organization. This means we accept horses of all ages, breeds, and conditions—including those who are elderly, injured, or unhandled—because every horse deserves safety and compassion.
We request a suggested intake fee of $500 to help offset the initial costs of care, including evaluation, feed, and basic medical needs during the first month. This fee is not required, but horses with a paid intake fee are given priority on the waiting list and are typically accepted more quickly. Horses without a fee may experience a longer wait, as space and funding are more limited.
Upon arrival, your horse will be evaluated by our experienced team. If necessary, a veterinarian will perform additional assessments such as dental exams and floating, x-rays, or lameness evaluations. A personalized rehabilitation plan will be developed based on your horse’s needs.
In cases where our veterinarians determine that a horse is suffering from an untreatable or painful condition with a poor prognosis, we will provide compassionate end-of-life care to ensure the horse does not continue to suffer.
A Note About Older Horses and Those Living with Pain
If your veterinarian has recommended euthanasia for a painful or untreatable condition, please know that we do not have access to any special resources or treatments that would change your horse’s prognosis. In these cases, we strongly encourage you to follow your veterinarian’s advice with confidence and compassion.
For older horses—particularly those in their mid-20s and beyond—it is often kinder and less stressful to allow them to pass peacefully at home, surrounded by the people and environment they know and trust. Transitioning to a new location, routine, and herd can be overwhelming for senior horses, especially those already struggling with pain or confusion.
If you’re facing this difficult decision, you don’t have to go through it alone. We can help in several ways:
- Be present with your horse during euthanasia if you’re unable to be there
- Provide transportation to a veterinary clinic if you do not have a trailer
- Offer support and guidance as you navigate this emotional process
We make these recommendations with great care and empathy. As an organization that regularly makes end-of-life decisions for horses we love, we truly understand how hard this can be.
Transportation of Your Horse
Once your horse has been approved for intake, you may schedule delivery to our facility. If you need assistance with transport, we may be able to help if volunteers are available, and we ask for a minimum of $2 per loaded mile to help cover fuel and time.
Please note:
- Transport help is not guaranteed, and our availability is extremely limited.
- We are rarely able to accommodate pickups over 300 miles away.
- For requests from greater distances (500–1,000+ miles), the cost will be significantly higher. In those cases, we may need to:
- Hire a professional hauler
- Cover hotel and meal expenses for a multi-day trip
- Coordinate complex logistics that can delay intake
We understand transportation can be a challenge, and we will do our best to work with you. However, we encourage owners from distant states to explore options closer to home when possible to reduce stress on the horse and minimize costs.
Horses coming from outside of South Dakota (except North Dakota) are required by law to have:
- A negative Coggins test
- A valid health certificate

Q. What is a "Full Circle of Life" Horse Shelter?
A Full Circle of Life Horse Shelter takes in any horse regardless of its health, temperament, old age, sickness, or adoptability. The term was first coined by Horse Plus Humane Society in Tennessee, and we have attended their FCOL workshop.
Q. Why do you charge an intake fee?
Unfortunately, horses are very expensive animals to provide care for. Most of the requests we get for intake will require significant veterinary costs in addition to the standard costs that every horse needs. Horses often require a longer period of time at the Shelter to find their home, which increases costs, and adoption fees rarely even cover the general costs. We are dependent on donations to provide help.
We recognize that in a crisis, some families can't afford an intake fee, and we can make hardship exceptions on a case by case basis.
Q. How long will I be on the waiting list?
We make every effort to bring in owner surrender horses as soon as funding and space allow. When an opening becomes available, a member of our intake team will reach out to confirm that you still need assistance and begin the intake process.
While we cannot guarantee a specific timeline, we aim to keep the wait as reasonable as possible. To help us manage the list and prioritize active needs, a team member will send a check-in email every two weeks.
If we do not receive a response after three consecutive check-ins, your application will be considered inactive and removed from the waiting list. If your situation changes after removal, you are always welcome to reapply at any time.
Q. What if a horse isn't adoptable? Do you euthanize for space?
No. Gentle Spirit Horses has never euthanized a horse due to lack of space, and we have no intention of doing so.
Our goal with every intake is rehabilitation and adoption. We believe that every horse deserves a chance, and our Pasture Pal companion program has helped find homes for many horses who might otherwise be overlooked due to age, injury, or limitations.
In rare cases where a horse is truly not adoptable—due to severe medical or behavioral challenges—we provide lifelong care through our hospice and long-term resident program. While we are not a sanctuary in the traditional sense, we do maintain space for a small number of horses who require permanent placement. We also work closely with partner organizations when needed to ensure those horses continue to receive quality care.
Our commitment is always to the horse’s quality of life. If a condition causes suffering with no path to comfort or healing, humane euthanasia may be considered—but never as a convenience or for space.
Q. Why do you rescue horses from auctions while having a waiting list for owner surrenders?
This is one of the most difficult parts of what we do, and we understand how hard it can be to see auction rescue efforts when you're waiting for help with your own horse.
As a rescue, our mission includes rehabilitating and rehoming horses, and we are not a sanctuary—meaning every horse we take in must eventually be adoptable. Many owner surrender requests involve horses who are older, have chronic health or behavioral issues, or are unlikely to be adopted. While we still strive to help these horses, they often require longer-term care and more resources, which limits how many we can take in at one time.
Most horses we rescue from auctions are chosen because they are in immediate danger, often facing slaughter or being passed over due to injury or neglect. While some auction horses go on to recover and find homes, others arrive with significant physical issues that require euthanasia within days or weeks of arrival to relieve suffering. We specifically look for horses that are most in need—not just the most adoptable—and do our best to give them a chance, even if that means offering them a peaceful end.
Auction rescues are also often funded by a different group of donors who are motivated by the urgency and visibility of those situations. These efforts help keep us in the public eye and support all of our work, including our ability to care for harder-to-place horses.
We work hard to balance both types of intake and recognize that every horse matters. We appreciate your understanding as we strive to help horses in need from all backgrounds.
Q. Do you provide updates after intake?
We are a working rescue and cannot guarantee individual updates, but we often share stories on our social media or website when horses are ready for adoption.
Q. Can I visit my horse after surrendering?
Yes, you may visit your horse by appointment as long as they remain in our care. We ask that you contact us in advance to schedule a visit, as we are a working facility and want to ensure a safe, quiet experience for both horses and visitors.
Once your horse is adopted, however, visitation is no longer possible. We respect the privacy of our adopters and strive to support a smooth transition for the horse into their new home. Many adopters choose to share occasional updates, but ongoing contact is not guaranteed and is at their discretion.
We understand this can be difficult, and we truly appreciate the trust you place in us when you surrender your horse.
Q. Can you take my horse for euthanasia?
In some cases, yes. We may be able to provide support with transportation, presence at euthanasia, or emotional guidance. Contact us to discuss.
Q. Will my horse be euthanized if surrendered?
Only when medically necessary and advised by our veterinary team. Every effort is made to provide quality of life or humane end-of-life care based on each horse’s needs.
Q. Will you tell me if my horse is euthanized?
Yes. If euthanasia is required for humane reasons while your horse is still in our care, we will notify you.
Q. Will my horse be adopted?
We are a rehabilitation and adoption-focused rescue. Horses who are sound, safe, and manageable are typically placed into homes. Those with more complex needs may remain longer or receive hospice care. We suggest reaching out to a Sanctuary based program if you are uncomfortable with the thought of your horse being adopted to a new family.
Q. Can I stay in touch with my horse’s adopter?
No. For the privacy of adopters and the security of the horse, we do not facilitate ongoing contact, but you’re welcome to follow our public updates.
Hardship Intake Fund
You can help us say "yes" to more owners by contributing to our Hardship Intake Fund. This fund allows us to waive the intake fee for families in crisis and provide immediate help.