Skip to content

Today we had to say goodbye to Simon, and it was one of the hardest things we've had to do in a long time.

Simon's story starts at a small local auction, where a long time friend and boarding barn owner purchased him as a lesson horse. His sweet personality and calm demeanor is what drew him in, and it helped that he was a stunning, tall boy. Unfortunately, he quickly showed a hitch in his hind leg, and on a farm vet check it became clear he would require further testing to determine what was wrong - but more importantly, that he would never be a safe lesson horse.
 
So they asked us to take him in, and we agreed, and promised to get to the bottom of what was wrong with him.
 
When he arrived, he showed even more personality - Simon was self-assured, confident, playful, and at times a nuisance. He made horse friends quickly, but then made it his duty to interfere when we wanted to catch them, galloping across pasture despite his hind end weirdness. The majority of the time he was the first to come say hello, but then would randomly decide it was a day to play keep away. There was always a sense of playfulness with Simon.
 
When vetted, we first suspected a stifle injury. He had a post-legged walk on the right hind, with a swing to the stifle and almost a stomp when setting it down. We x-rayed every joint, but found nothing. There was no obvious swelling in the stifle. What we did have was weight loss and muscle wasting, and the lameness, so we decided two things: to test him for EPM and send video of his lameness exam and x-rays to a specialist for review. We got two answers: the specialist believed that the gait was a conformational issue that couldn't be corrected, but could be managed with muscle building and activity, and a positive EPM test.
 
The good news is with four months of medication, Simon eventually had a negative EPM test. He gained weight and muscle, and his coordination improved. The bad news was that he did have obvious long-term neurological damage from the EPM. He was pasture sound, but we'd never feel comfortable making him a riding horse. Instead, we quietly stopped sharing him as adoptable, other than the occasional pasture pal placements. As fall approached, we even had him scheduled to go live at Shepherd's Stable, as one of their foster horses is not a fan of being stalled overnight, so he seemed like the perfect sweet, funny boy to swap places.
 
But then, things started to change. He started to drop weight, so we brought him up to the grain pen for dinner. He started to have some coordination issues, and then his right hind swelled up and he really struggled. We cancelled the plans for Shepherd's Stable and started planning for euthanasia. The changing temps, rain and cold, made us think the damage from EPM was too much, and winter would be dangerous. We told our volunteers our plans, and fully expected to say goodbye at our fall veterinary day.
 
But then we noticed the puncture wound, and as it recovered the swelling went down. He started to walk better, then started packing the weight back on, and his playful personality came back. He would follow us around if we had buckets, insisting that all the food is for him. He would get into things he shouldn't have, and often when he laid down we'd see him dog sit for a while before getting up completely. I think that's how I'll probably remember him, sitting like a dog, letting me come up and look him in the eyes and love on him. He was able to get himself up - though it was still awkward at times, but getting better, but he was getting stronger.
 
And we started to think maybe it wasn't time.
 
The last few weeks have been rainy and cold, our ground is saturated, and mud was hard on him. So he spent it roaming the main part of the farm with 27-yr-old Jazz, so we didn't have to stress him being in a herd or the mud causing problems as he recovered from the infection. For some reason, today they went to the woods, and to do that had to cross a very muddy area. At 8:00 a.m. he was pestering Nina for attention as she left for work; by 9:30 a.m. he was stuck in a large patch of clay, digging his good leg deeper and deeper as he tried to get out, and unable to do it in the clay. I found him dog sitting, waiting for help, as he always did. So trusting, sweet, and willing.
 
But clay is sticky, and slippery, and pulls you in the harder you try to get out. I think I knew the minute I saw him that we were fighting a losing battle. I tried, and I stressed, and then I switched off the emotions and turned on the problem solving. I asked for, and got help for Simon. Our neighbor came with his tractor (I'm scared to drive ours). Nina got the message and came home, picking up straps. I reviewed the forward assist procedure to make sure I knew what to do. We would have to pull him out of the hole using from the front.
 
And I called the vet, and told them I highly suspected I was going to need them to euthanize him, even if we got him out of the clay. It was 45 degrees F, drizzling, and slippery. I admit, I was hopeful since he had been stuck for such a short time, that if we got him out of the clay and to firmer ground, that he would get up. I really, really thought that would happen.
 
But it wasn't meant to be. He simply couldn't get up, and he was cold and wet. We got him out of the clay, piled the blankets on and rubbed him dry, and made sure he was able to put his head on dry ground. We piled straw around him to try and firm up the ground even more, and we fought hard to help him stand. It became clear that he had reinjured his back legs, and while we considered taking the next steps to help him - a sling, pulling him into the barn, steroids - we also had to consider that he was getting colder, and stressed, and there was still a good chance that we would be saying goodbye to him in the next couple of weeks anyway.
 
So as the vet pulled in, even though it was impossible to actually say it at first, we knew that asking him to fight was more for us than him, and that it would be much kinder and more fair to him to let him go. So we did. And it was hard, in every way you can imagine. It was by far the hardest good bye we've ever had to do, and we are struggling hard.
 
But Simon no longer is. Simon was able to close his eyes, surrounded by love, and open them again in the greener pastures we imagine all horses go to. He no longer felt the cold rain, or the mud, no longer had to worry about if his legs were going to betray him, and I imagine is running as fast and free as he used to gallop through our pastures, chasing the girls and causing a general ruckus. Because that's what horses with big, playful, sweet personalities do.
 
And maybe once in a while, he'll lie down, then sit up like a dog, looking around, and just appreciating the beautiful world, and he'll have a slight memory of us coming up, looking him in the eye, and loving on him.